Late last week, I transferred my last sale chicken from the freezer to the fridge to thaw. At the time, I planned on making "Lemony Chicken" from the April/May 2009 issue of
Cook's Country magazine for Sunday's supper. I had lemons. I had chicken. I had a plan.
But.
But then we visited my parents on Saturday and I mentioned how I was looking for the "
recipe for
Lemon Lover's Cake" which I thought was in a 2008
Cook's Country. My mother, who has a pretty complete run, dragged out Ought Eight and we went to town looking for that cake recipe. And we found it ... photocopied and stuffed into February/March 2008. Where did the photocopy come from? It is a mystery. Search results suggest the recipe appeared in an April/May issue of
Cook's Country magazine, but hers is not a magazine copy -- it came out of a book. Which book? Why?
And who really cares? For in that February/March 2008 issue appeared "Ultimate Garlic Roast Chicken." Forget "Lemony Chicken" for garlic will always win in my kitchen.
This chicken was quite fun to make. Oh, the recipe does call for a fair amount of fiddliness, but the results were well worth it. Yes, you could skip making your own garlic oil and buy a bottle in the condiment aisle. Yes, you could (probably) skip making your own garlic paste and buy the refrigerated stuff in a tube. But, then, why not buy a garlic-pepper rotisserie chicken and a tub of refrigerated garlic mashed potatoes and have done?
This was Sunday supper and Sunday supper requires extra fiddliness, goshdarnit.

So, we peeled many garlic cloves (three heads worth = about 60 cloves of varying sizes). Then I cooked them in olive oil until they were softened and "straw colored." I set a bit of garlic oil aside and puréed the rest in my food processor until the garlic formed a thick (mostly smooth) paste. I flavored a bit of the paste with salt and pepper and smeared it under the skin of the breasts, thighs, and leg of the prepped chicken.
(I should note that the recipe calls for trussing up the chicken, but I could not find my kitchen string. No matter, the chicken was fine without the extra fuss).
After smearing the chicken, I popped it (breast down) into the 375 oven and let it roast until a beautiful gold. While the chicken roasted, I combined the rest of the garlic paste with Riesling and low-sodium chicken broth. Then I grabbed the chicken with a bunch of paper towels (this was the messiest bit) and flipped it over. Turned the oven up to 450, poured the broth mixture into the bottom of the roasting pan and let it go for about 40 minutes.
When the chicken was done, I let it sit for 20 minutes (as directed) while I made the mashed potatoes and pan sauce. The potatoes used the
The America's Test Kitchen Family Cookbook recipe I love so much and were originally meant to have garlic in them, too, but I changed my mind at the last minute -- afraid it might actually be
too much garlic. The tarragon pan sauce was, alas, a miss. Too buttery and not garlicky or chicken-y enough for me.
The pan sauce's failure was not a big deal in the grand scheme of things. The chicken was so moist and garlicky that it needed no sauce. Ditto the potatoes which were so perfectly buttered and creamed, I could have eaten them all by themselves. But, I didn't. No, I stirred my microwaved corn into them like any good six-year-old.
Would I make this chicken again? Yes. I would skip the pan sauce, but otherwise can think of no way this dish could be improved.